Advantages & disadvantages of the jury system 2209 words | 9 pages the jury system the nature and composition of the jury the jury system of a trial is an essential element of the democratic process. The jury system is designed to ensure that justice prevails through the use of a fair trial by one's peers however, it is a flawed system strengths weaknesses represents a cross-section of the community: juries are ideally made up of community members of all different occupations, age, education level, gender, race, culture and sexuality. Advantages provides certainty, no retrial (subject to recent reforms but only for serious crimes) retrial available in tainted cases (nobbling) section 54 criminal procedure and investigation act 1996. Advantages of jury trial + public confidence - the jury is considered as one of the fundamentals of a democratic society the right to be tried by one's peers is a bastion of liberty against the state and has been supported by eminent judges. 1 prevents bias with a jury trial, bias is highly unlikely since the 12 members of the jury are picked out randomly in most cases, the jury is selected outside the judicial system to ensure fair trial and reduce the risk of bias verdict.
Advantages provides certainty, no retrial (subject to recent reforms but only for serious crimes) retrial available in tainted cases (nobbling) section 54 criminal procedure. Open system of justice - lord devlin said: 'a jury is the lamp over society to show freedom lives' balance against state interferance - harder for individuals of the government to bribe a whole jury rather than just one judge, making the overall process fairer. Was asked to enumerate the advantages and disadvantages of the grand jury system as they appeared to him of 121 questionnaires sent out, thirty-nine were returned of these twenty-si'l: stated.
Best answer: advantages: 1 if you are being tried, you will get your day in court and have an opportunity to clear your name 2 the determination of your innocence or guilt is not made by a judge, or panel of judges, appointed by the government (the way it is in many countries. The jury system was instituted in the united states so that instead of a judge determining a person's sentence, a group of peers in that community would do so something magical happens when you put a group of people into a room and let them hear a legal case the advantage here is that a personal. Criticism of the jury system in criminal trial process has emphasised the high cost of juries to the court system in addition the technical nature and trials difficulty for lay people to understand purportedly leads to unintentional jury nullification. What are the advantages to a jury trial many people believe that they will get a fairer trial if they appear in front of a jury when you are tried by a jury, the idea is that you are being tried by your peers rather than a single magistrate or judge, who may or may not be able to relate to your personal circumstances.
Advantages provides certainty, no retrial (subject to recent reforms but only for serious crimes) prosecution and defence challenges correct the problems caused by random selection. The advantages and disadvantages depend on many things, such as the professionalism of the judge (influenced but not conclusively determined by the level of the court and the jurisdiction), the nature of the case, the complexity of applicable law, the method of jury selection, the criteria for a verdict, etc. Members of a jury use common sense to decide if an accused person is guilty or innocent of a crime. Search results australia's unfair legal system in theory all jury systems (which have existed for almost 800 years) are fair and just the jury system originated in england and has so far failed in cases (all too common) when defendants are wrongfully prosecuted or convicted of crimes which they.
Force on jury system improvements, the administrative office of the courts sought a review of social disadvantages of reducing the size of a jury the purported. End the jury what are the advantages of the jury system a jury provides a final, clear answer, with no need for retrial (subject to recent reforms, but only for serious crimes. Disadvantages of trial by jury from my experience the main issue with jury trials is that they can be heavily influenced by personalities the eloquence of the defence and prosecution barristers is very significant but don't underestimate the influence of members of the jury as well. Advantages and disadvantages of the jury system advantages of the jury system long established trial by peers which has public confidence lord devlin, a famous house of lords judge, has said that trial by jury is the lamp that shows that freedom lives, arguing that a defendant has the right to be tried by his peers. The criminal justice system in america has both advantages and disadvantages the process of the criminal justice system is different from state to state the federal criminal justice system is also different from the states' criminal justice system, featuring its own procedures, rules, and legal terms to describe the various aspects of the proceedings.
Today some wonder whether the days of jury trials should be over, or whether the advantages of the jury system still outweigh the disadvantages in nsw it is your right to trial by jury if you are charged with an indictable offence - but since 1990 you also have the right to trial by judge alone, if you think that this would serve your. Advantages of the jury system jury will provide a sympathetic hearing (a fairer one) the jury has no previous knowledge of case and can give an unbiased decision. The jury system one of the major component of the british legal system is the jury system the presence of '12 good men and true' gave the assumption that it strengthens the legitimacy of the legal system. Jury is not empanelled advantages and disadvantages of the jury system trial by jury is only one of many possible means of adjudicating serious cases in most of europe.
The jury system the nature and composition of the jury the jury system of a trial is an essential element of the democratic process it attempts to secure fairness in the justice system. Maybe it shouldn't be left up to you and me to judge our fellow citizens how about a panel of pro jurors to be established having spent the better part of the last two weeks watching an.